any guesses on who charlotte might be my guess would be bens long lost love.

that's exactly what I was thinking. But she seems much younger than Ben?

quote:

Originally posted by oilida:
any guesses on who charlotte might be my guess would be bens long lost love.

Do you mean the girl that Ben hung out in his flashback in end of season 3? She had freckles and so does Charlotte

Im going to guess shes bens real daughter and the mother, His lil friend from his flashback, was taken off the island by her father , Widmore

So Mikeyraw you are suggesting Charlotte is Penny's sister? I think she's too old to be Bens daughter but too young to be the little playmate of his. I need to rewatch that episode if I can remember which one it was.I just don't know if we have been introduced to her island connection or if that will simply be something for next year, she does seem well educated and wealthy in her daring ,carefree way. She may very well be a Widmore. Wouldn't it be amazing if Penny turned out to be bad and in on the con with her Dad because she wanted to get back to the island too and knew that Des was the puppet to do it.

quote:

Originally posted by islander:
Wouldn't it be amazing if Penny turned out to be bad and in on the con with her Dad because she wanted to get back to the island too and knew that Des was the puppet to do it.

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
That would break my heart. The scenes between Penny and Desmond have been so touching. I will never forgive them if this comes to pass.

quote:

Originally posted by patcon:

quote:

Originally posted by islander:
Wouldn't it be amazing if Penny turned out to be bad and in on the con with her Dad because she wanted to get back to the island too and knew that Des was the puppet to do it.

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
That would break my heart. The scenes between Penny and Desmond have been so touching. I will never forgive them if this comes to pass.

That may be true, but it would be a brilliant twist to the story.

quote:

Originally posted by LOST_MY_HEAD:

quote:

Originally posted by patcon:

quote:

Originally posted by islander:
Wouldn't it be amazing if Penny turned out to be bad and in on the con with her Dad because she wanted to get back to the island too and knew that Des was the puppet to do it.

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
That would break my heart. The scenes between Penny and Desmond have been so touching. I will never forgive them if this comes to pass.

That may be true, but it would be a brilliant twist to the story.

It would certainly be a twist, but I think the show would immediately shed a LOT of viewers. I'm in total agreement w/patcon.

I know, I know, but it would be a twist which the writers love. There has to be more to the Des/Penny story it seemed too convenient for them to sail off into the sunset.The key might be with Charlotte.

I've got a feeling that Pennys boat is going to bump in to the raft with Desmonds Constant onboard. Dan, isn't it? Hes still getting a suntan at sea. & then probably somhow end up back on the Island. As soon as Desmond said "I'm never setting foot there again", to Sayid, I thought to myself - "Never say never, Dude".

Great thought Rhys. There had to be more reason to the whole "constant" episode and this would be a perfect senario to delve deeper into it.

Actually, Desmond's constant is Penny.
Desmond is Farady's constant.

But, I agree that somehow Desmond and Faraday will be reunited. Desmond and Penny are too interesting to lose as central characters. I can see Desmond getting a frantic message that Faraday is sufferign form the 'sickness' and that only Desmond's return can save him. Desmond owes him so much (his life, in fact) that Desmond goes back.

Back to the question of bens possible love... I still want to know who Sarah (Jacks EX) has started dating. I remember there was quite a bit of secrecy over that - Im still guessing ... BEN? Didn't Ben say to Jack that Juliet was alot like Sarah? And we know now, that Ben wants a piece of Juliete.. so why wouldn't he want a piece of Sarah?